The arrest of Gabriela Saldana is not just legally flawed; it is an embarrassment to the justice system.
Read more Wish granted: Girl plays with dolphins
This troubling case involving an FIU student should concern anyone who values constitutional freedoms. Gabriela Saldana was arrested over a WhatsApp message that read: “Netanyahu, if you can hear me, drop some bonbons for us Capstone students in Ocean Bank Convocation Center.”
For that statement, which was flippant, hyperbolic, and detached from reality, she now faces criminal prosecution. A college student sends a WhatsApp message jokingly calling on Benjamin Netanyahu to “drop bombs,” and suddenly we are pretending this is a credible threat?
That should alarm us all.
The First Amendment does not protect only polite or well considered speech. It protects speech that is messy, exaggerated, sarcastic, and even offensive. The line between protected speech and criminal conduct is deliberately high. Under Supreme Court precedent, only “true threats,” meaning statements that convey a serious intent to commit unlawful violence, fall outside constitutional protection.
And crucially, those threats must be credible.
In Virginia v. Black, the Court defined a true threat as a serious expression of intent to commit violence. More recently, in Counterman v. Colorado, the Court reinforced that the speaker must at least consciously disregard the risk that their words would be interpreted as a real threat.
This is neither serious nor credible.
There is no intent. No capability. No connection to reality. Just an exaggerated, arguably stupid remark in a group chat.
To call that a threat is to strip the word of its meaning.
There is no plausible argument that Saldana had any ability to carry out the supposed threat. She does not have access to Benjamin Netanyahu. She does not control military assets. She does not possess the means, intent, or capability to orchestrate violence. The statement itself reads less like a plan and more like a poorly phrased joke, one that mirrors the kind of exaggerated commentary common across social media.
To treat it as a credible threat is to abandon reality.
Yet Judge Mindy S. Glazer determined that there is probable cause for this case to proceed to trial, although she has hinted that the prosecution may struggle to prove its case. That decision reflects a troubling shift, one in which courts blur the line between offensive speech and criminal conduct.
If this standard holds, the implications are severe.
Even more troubling is the role of prosecutors. Bringing charges in a case so clearly lacking the elements of a true threat does not enhance public safety; it undermines confidence in the justice system. Courts exist to address genuine harm, not to police ill considered jokes.
Read more Miami-Dade County Parks leads way for a more accessible future
This case should not survive judicial scrutiny. It lacks credibility, intent, and imminence, the core elements required to criminalize speech. Allowing it to proceed risks setting a precedent in which absurdity itself becomes evidence of criminal intent.
If the courts adopt this standard, then no speech is safe. Every joke becomes evidence. Every exaggeration becomes intent.
That is not constitutional law. That is authoritarian logic.
This case should be dismissed immediately, not just because it is weak, but because allowing it to continue damages the very foundation of free speech.
Sincerely,
Parham Pahlevani
ABOUT US:
For more Miami community news, look no further than Miami Community Newspapers. This Miami online group of newspapers covers a variety of topics about the local community and beyond. Miami’s Community Newspapers offers daily news, online resources, podcasts and other multimedia content to keep readers informed. With topics ranging from local news to community events, Miami’s Community Newspapers is the ideal source for staying up to date with the latest news and happenings in the area.
This family-owned media company publishes more than a dozen neighborhood publications, magazines, special sections on their websites, newsletters, as well as distributing them in print throughout Miami Dade County from Aventura, Sunny Isles Beach, Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Brickell, Coconut Grove, Pinecrest, South Miami, Kendall, Palmetto Bay, Cutler Bay and Homestead. Each online publication and print editions provide comprehensive coverage of local news, events, business updates, lifestyle features, and local initiatives within its respective community.
Additionally, the newspaper has exclusive Miami community podcasts, providing listeners with an in-depth look into Miami’s culture. Whether you’re looking for local Miami news, or podcasts, Miami’s Community Newspapers has you covered. For more information, be sure to check out: https://communitynewspapers.com.
If you have any questions, feel free to email [email protected] or [email protected].
Read more Localized Miami: Robert Ruano and guest, Commissioner Lynn Su, of City of North Miami